What Are You Paying For?
The shared ingredient gives you a useful starting point, but it does not prove identical purity, mixing performance, or results. This comparison has not established that one brand produces greater strength gains.
Use the cost calculator above, or divide each tub price by its listed servings:
Nutricost: price ÷ 100
Optimum Nutrition: price ÷ 120
Thorne: price ÷ 90
Use the same basis for each: one-time purchase or subscription, applicable discounts, and any shipping charges. Confirm the unflavored size before ordering. Flavored products, bundles, and other sizes may have different serving counts.
What Thorne's Certification Tells You
NSF Certified for Sport includes checks related to label contents, contaminants, and banned substances.[5] That is relevant if sport certification is one of your buying requirements. It does not establish that Thorne builds more muscle than the other two.
This review independently checked Thorne's NSF entry; it did not comprehensively audit the other brands' testing programs. Do not interpret that limited check as evidence that the other products are untested or unsafe.
Buying Creatine After 50?
Keep your training plan in the picture. A 2026 review of trials in generally healthy adults aged 60 and older found a modest additional strength benefit from creatine alongside resistance training. Benefits for muscle mass and everyday physical function were less certain.[6]
That evidence supports a measured reason to consider creatine. It does not establish that these three products prevent falls, reverse aging, or replace exercise. The findings also should not be assumed to apply to frail adults or everyone with a medical condition.
If you have kidney disease, take prescription medication, or have an existing medical condition, ask your clinician or pharmacist whether creatine fits your situation before buying. Follow the product directions; the 5 g figures above describe the labels, not a personalized prescription.
Which One Would I Shortlist?
For everyday comparison shopping, check Nutricost and Optimum Nutrition first and do the per-serving calculation. For a buyer specifically seeking NSF Certified for Sport, Thorne is the option with a directory entry verified for this comparison.
Open the links above, check the selected size and seller, and choose based on your requirements and the current checkout price.
Check the three Amazon options ↑
Sources & verification
- Nutricost product specifications; 500 g / 5 g = 100 servings, also matched to the linked Amazon listing in our November 8 product audit
- Optimum Nutrition U.S. product page, unflavored 120-serving selection
- Thorne Creatine, 90 servings
- NSF Certified for Sport product and lot listing
- NSF: What Our Mark Means
- Resistance training plus creatine in older adults: systematic review and meta-analysis, 2026


