Fitness · Research · 6 min read
A planned week off: similar muscle growth, possibly less strength
In a 2024 randomized trial, trained lifters who took a full week off halfway through a 9-week program grew a similar amount of leg muscle to those who kept training. Their strength gains tended to be a little smaller, but that result is uncertain.
A deload is a short easier stretch, usually about a week, and it's a common habit among coaches and lifters. The hope is that the break clears fatigue and leaves your muscles more responsive when you come back. A 2024 trial in PeerJ tested a blunt version of that: one full week with no lifting, halfway through a hard 9-week program. Muscle growth came out similar to training straight through. Strength gains tended to be a little smaller after the week off, but that part is uncertain. [1]
What the researchers did
The team at Lehman College in New York recruited 50 adults aged 18 to 40 who had lifted at least three times a week for at least a year. They were randomly split into two groups, and 39 finished: 18 in the week-off group (12 men, 6 women) and 21 in the continuous group (17 men, 4 women). Average lifting experience was 3.7 years in the week-off group and 3.2 years in the continuous group. The methods were registered online before recruitment started. [1]
Both groups followed the same upper/lower split for 9 weeks, four sessions a week. Leg days were supervised: Smith machine squat, leg extension, straight-leg toe press and seated calf raise, 5 sets of 8 to 12 reps each, with staff encouraging people to go to failure, and 2 minutes of rest between sets. Upper-body days were done on their own. The week-off group did no resistance training at all in week 5 but could keep doing cardio or sport. [1]
That's a lot of work. The authors put it at 90 sets per week across all muscle groups combined. Muscle thickness was measured by ultrasound at three points along the front and side of the thigh and at three calf muscles, and the person doing the scans didn't know who was in which group. The results are reported with Bayesian statistics, so you'll see credible intervals instead of p-values. [1]
Key findings
| Outcome | Difference | 95% credible interval | Chance the week off came out ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strength and performance (Table 3) | |||
| Smith machine squat 1RM | −3.6 kg | −10.4 to 3.2 | 0.149 |
| Isometric knee extension | −14.4 N·m | −34.3 to 5.8 | 0.076 |
| Leg extension reps (endurance) | −0.55 reps | −2.9 to 1.9 | 0.321 |
| Countermovement jump | 0.61 cm | −1.5 to 2.8 | 0.715 |
| Muscle thickness (Table 2) | |||
| Nine thigh and calf sites (multivariate column) | −0.63 to 0.53 mm | All cross zero | 0.273 to 0.835 |
| Difference = gain in the week-off group minus gain in the continuous group. Negative = the continuous group gained more. "Chance the week off came out ahead" is the paper's posterior probability favoring the week off. Strength and performance rows use the right-hand (univariate) columns of Table 3. Table 2's column labels and the paper's text disagree on which analysis is univariate; values here are from the column printed as multivariate. [1] | |||
Muscle growth: similar. Both groups added muscle thickness over the 9 weeks. The differences between groups were all small, ranging from −0.63 to 0.53 mm across the nine sites, and every credible interval crossed zero. There was no clear sign that the week off held muscle growth back, and no sign of a boost either. [1]
“Both groups increased muscle size over the course of the study, with similar between-group increases observed in all measurements.”
— Coleman et al., PeerJ 2024, Discussion. [1: Full text]
Strength: leaning toward training straight through. Both groups got stronger. On average, though, the continuous group gained a bit more in both the squat and the isometric knee extension test. The paper puts the probability that continuous training came out ahead at 0.851 for the squat and 0.924 for the knee extension. Both intervals still include zero, so a small edge the other way can't be ruled out. [1]
“For 1RM squat testing, the results were somewhat more equivocal, but nevertheless indicate a potential benefit for TRAD.”
— Coleman et al., PeerJ 2024, Discussion. TRAD is the continuous group. [1: Full text]
Jump and leg endurance: no real difference. Leg extension reps differed by less than one rep, which the authors say isn't likely to matter in practice. The jump result was close to zero as well. [1]
“Differences between groups in CMJ performance were trivial.”
— Coleman et al., PeerJ 2024, Discussion. CMJ is the countermovement jump. [1: Full text]
How it felt. In a readiness-to-train questionnaire, the week-off group reported more muscle soreness and less motivation at the end than after week 4. In the continuous group, soreness went down and motivation held steady. There was some evidence of better sleep quality in the week-off group around the middle of the study. The authors call these differences modest. They also mention that people in the week-off group often said they felt sluggish and out of practice when they came back, rather than refreshed. That last point is anecdotal, not a measured result. [1]
One more detail stood out to me. Nearly everyone said they'd trained harder than ever before during the study, yet almost no one felt they needed a break at the end. [1]
What this doesn't tell us
- The "deload" here was a complete stop. In practice, coaches and lifters often deload by cutting sets, weight or effort for a week instead. The authors say their results only apply to stopping entirely.
- Only the legs were measured. Upper-body training was unsupervised and the training logs were often patchy, so nothing can be said about upper-body muscles.
- The group was small (39 people), young and already trained. It doesn't tell us about beginners, teenagers or people over 40.
- The week-off group also simply lifted for one week less (8 training weeks vs 9), so the comparison is a break versus an extra week of training.
- Nine weeks is short. The break came after four weeks on a fixed schedule, so the results may not carry over to longer programs or to breaks taken when you feel run down.
- The program was built for muscle growth with moderate loads. The authors note a strength-focused program with heavier loads might respond differently.
“Finally, our results are specific to a deload involving a cessation of RT.”
— Coleman et al., PeerJ 2024, Limitations. RT is resistance training. [1: Full text]
Funding is worth knowing about here. The study was supported by a grant from Renaissance Periodization, LLC, which had a role in the study design and in preparing the manuscript. One author, Michael Israetel, is a cofounder of that company, and another, Brad Schoenfeld, serves on the scientific advisory board of Tonal, a fitness equipment maker. The person scanning muscles and the statistician were both blinded to group. [1]
What to take away
If you're a young, already-trained lifter training for muscle and wondering whether a scheduled week off will set you back, this trial suggests it probably won't, at least for your legs over a couple of months. It also didn't find the "come back bigger" bonus that people often hope for. If strength is your main goal, the numbers lean the other way: the group that kept training tended to gain a bit more. The authors suggest that a lighter week, rather than a full stop, might clear fatigue without the sluggish feeling, but this study didn't test that.
“Perhaps a period of reduced training volume and intensity, but not complete cessation, would allow for the dissipation of fatigue without bringing about a feeling of lethargy upon return.”
— Coleman et al., PeerJ 2024, Discussion. [1: Full text]
A quick safety note. This was a planned break in healthy young adults. It says nothing about time off for pain or injury. If you have either, or a health condition, check with a qualified professional before you change how you train.
Reference
- PeerJ 2024[1] Coleman M, Burke R, Augustin F, Piñero A, Maldonado J, Fisher JP, Israetel M, Androulakis Korakakis P, Swinton P, Oberlin D, Schoenfeld BJ. Gaining more from doing less? The effects of a one-week deload period during supervised resistance training on muscular adaptations. PeerJ. 2024;12:e16777.
DOI: 10.7717/peerj.16777 · Full text · Open access (CC BY 4.0)
This article is for education only and isn't medical advice.
