Elmsword
← Fitness

Fitness · Research · 2 min read

Leg press and knee extension cover different muscles

A direct comparison found a larger rectus femoris increase with knee extension, while leg press also grew the gluteus maximus and adductor magnus. A whole-quadriceps result can hide differences between muscles.

What the researchers did

The contralateral-leg comparison included 17 untrained adults over 12 weeks, twice weekly, using five sets of ten repetitions at 70% 1RM. MRI assessed 17 muscles. Legs were assigned to each exercise with dominant and non-dominant legs counterbalanced; the paper does not describe this as random.

Key findings

Key findings
MuscleExtension volume change (%)Press volume change (%)Comparison
Rectus femoris+13.2%+1.1%p≤.001
Whole quadriceps+7.1%+4.9%No clear difference
Gluteus maximusNo significant increase (range −0.9% to +0.2%)15.4%Press increase
Adductor magnusNo significant increase (range −0.9% to +0.2%)6.2%Press increase
Source: Kinoshita et al. abstract · Study source
Leg press and knee extension cover different muscles
Reported changes; numerical confidence intervals unavailable. Kinoshita et al.

How to read the result

The rectus femoris comparison is more specific than a statement about the quadriceps as a whole. The leg press findings show why an exercise can remain useful even when it produces less growth in a particular muscle.

Limitations

The study did not test a combined routine or an optimal split between exercises. The 17 participants were untrained. Whole-quadriceps growth was comparable between exercises (P ≥ 0.319), which does not prove the two are equivalent.

How to apply it

Consider exercise selection in terms of muscle coverage. Knee extension and leg press can serve complementary roles when those muscles are priorities.

Sources

  1. StudyKinoshita M, Maeo S, Kobayashi Y, Eihara Y, Nishizawa N, Kusagawa Y, Sugiyama T, Wakahara T, Kanehisa H, Isaka T. Hypertrophic Effects of Single- versus Multi-Joint Exercise: A Direct Comparison between Knee Extension and Leg Press.
    DOI: 10.1249/MSS.0000000000003957 · PubMed abstract · Full text (PMC)

This article explains research for educational use.