THE WHEY PROTEIN COMPARISON

Which whey protein
should you buy?

Optimum Nutrition, Dymatize ISO100, or NOW Sports. Look at protein per scoop, scoops per tub, and which testing program lists each one.

By Elmsword · U.S. products · Specifications checked November 13, 2026

Compare your prices ↓

How much protein a day? See what a 49-trial meta-analysis found ↓

WHEY COST CALCULATOR

Which tub costs less per gram of protein?

Enter the prices you see. The scoops hold 24 g or 25 g, so we compare cost per 100 g of protein.

Prices in USD. Include shipping and apply discounts for a fair comparison.

Optimum Nutrition

5 lb tub · Double Rich Chocolate

Cost per 100 g protein
—
Cost per scoop
—
Scoops per tub
74

Dymatize ISO100

5 lb tub · Fudge Brownie

Cost per 100 g protein
—
Cost per scoop
—
Scoops per tub
70

NOW Sports

5 lb tub · Unflavored

Cost per 100 g protein
—
Cost per scoop
—
Scoops per tub
81

Enter at least two prices to find the lowest cost.

Compare any two, or all three.

Protein per tub uses the labels for the sizes and flavors above: 74 × 24 g, 70 × 25 g, and 81 × 24 g.

Three 5 lb tubs, side by side.

Two are flavored and one is unflavored. All three list 24 g or 25 g of protein per scoop. Sources ↓

NSF Certified for Sport listing

Optimum Nutrition

Gold Standard Whey, Double Rich Chocolate

74scoops
24 g protein each

5 lb · Whey isolate and concentrate

Amazon's #1 best seller in Sports Nutrition Whey when we checked. NSF lists this flavor, so check your tub's lot number against the listing.

Check ON on Amazon Paid link · Confirm size, flavor, and seller

Informed Choice listing

Dymatize ISO100

Hydrolyzed Whey Isolate, Fudge Brownie

70scoops
25 g protein each

5 lb · Hydrolyzed whey isolate

The most protein per scoop of the three. Informed Choice lists tested Fudge Brownie batches for this product.

Check ISO100 on Amazon Paid link · Confirm size, flavor, and seller

Unflavored · Most scoops

NOW Sports

Whey Protein Isolate, Unflavored

81scoops
24 g protein each

5 lb · Whey isolate and sunflower lecithin

Nothing added for flavor, so it stirs into a smoothie or oatmeal. NOW's product page lists Informed Sport.

Check NOW on Amazon Paid link · Confirm size and seller
How we compared them: Published specifications and evidence, not hands-on testing or a head-to-head trial. Buying recommendations are editorial judgments (inferences) from those features. Confidence is higher in the listed specifications than in any prediction of which product will suit you.

How Much Protein Does the Research Point To?

A 2018 meta-analysis in the British Journal of Sports Medicine pooled 49 randomized controlled trials with 1,863 participants. Each trial paired resistance exercise training (RET) with either a protein supplement or a control, and ran for 6 weeks or longer.[6]

Training alone added about 1.1 kg of fat-free mass (FFM), which is roughly your weight minus fat. Adding protein put another 0.30 kg of FFM on top of that, and raised strength gains on one-repetition maximum (1RM) by 2.49 kg.[6]

Once total intake passed 1.62 g of protein per kilogram of body weight per day (g/kg/day), more protein didn't add more FFM. The 95% confidence interval ran from 1.03 to 2.20, so the authors suggest about 2.2 g/kg/day for people trying to get the most out of their training.[6]

Example: 70 kg × 1.62 g = about 113 g of protein a day

One scoop on this page: 24 g or 25 g

That daily number counts food and powder together.

The benefit for FFM got smaller with age and was bigger in people who already lifted. The authors also concluded that timing, post-workout dose, and protein source play "a minor, if any, role" in FFM and strength gains over weeks. All the trials enrolled people eating at or above their energy needs, so these numbers don't cover dieting.[6]

What the Testing Listings Tell You

NSF Certified for Sport includes checks related to label contents, contaminants, and banned substances.[5] NSF lists Gold Standard whey in Double Rich Chocolate for sale in the U.S. That listing names a 4.53 kg package and five lot numbers. The 5 lb tub linked here isn't named on it, so check the lot printed on your tub.[4]

Informed Choice lists ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder (USA), with Fudge Brownie batches in its test table.[7] NOW's own product page lists Informed Sport.[3] We checked those three listings only. None of them shows that one powder builds more muscle than another.

Before You Buy

All three are made from milk. If you have a milk allergy, kidney disease, or another medical condition, or you take prescription medication, ask your clinician or pharmacist whether a protein supplement fits your situation. Follow the label directions. The numbers above describe labels and a study average, not a personal prescription.

The NOW Amazon listing shows 24 g in its title and 25g in its nutrition panel. NOW's own site says 24 g per 28 g scoop, which is the number this page uses. Read the label on the tub you get.[3]

Our Shortlist

For a flavored everyday shake, start with Optimum Nutrition and put its price into the calculator next to ISO100. For an unflavored powder you can stir into food, go with NOW.

Open the links above, check the size, flavor, and seller, and decide on the current checkout price.

Check the three Amazon options ↑

Sources & verification

  1. Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey, Double Rich Chocolate, 5 lb, Amazon listing: 24 g protein per scoop, 74 servings per container, checked November 13, 2026
  2. Dymatize ISO100 product page: 25 g protein per serving; Amazon listing, Fudge Brownie 5 lb: 70 servings
  3. NOW Sports Whey Protein Isolate, Unflavored: 24 g protein per 28 g scoop, about 81 servings in 5 lbs, ingredients, Informed Sport listed under Awards
  4. NSF Certified for Sport product and lot listing: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard whey, Double Rich Chocolate
  5. NSF: What Our Mark Means
  6. Morton RW et al. A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of the effect of protein supplementation on resistance training-induced gains in muscle mass and strength in healthy adults. Br J Sports Med. 2018;52:376–384. DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2017-097608 (49 randomized controlled trials, 1,863 participants; eligibility: RET of 6 weeks or longer). A 2020 correction adds that one author served on the advisory board of Dymatize Nutrition.
  7. Informed Choice: ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder (USA), certified product and batch table

Product options and prices can change. Check the selected size, flavor, seller, and current checkout price before ordering.