Elmsword
← Sleep

Sleep · Research · 5 min read

Tai chi and insomnia: slower gains, non-inferior by month 15

A trial in adults aged 50 and over found larger early improvements with CBT-I. At month 15, tai chi met the study's threshold for non-inferiority.

Can tai chi help people with chronic insomnia? A Hong Kong trial compared it with cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia (CBT-I). The timing matters: CBT-I produced a larger improvement after the three-month program. At month 15, the difference was small enough for tai chi to meet the trial's preset comparison rule. [1]

What the researchers compared

The researchers randomly assigned 200 adults aged 50 or over with chronic insomnia to tai chi or CBT-I, with 100 people in each group. Both groups attended 24 one-hour group sessions over three months. This was a structured program with substantial class time; it does not tell us what an occasional tai chi session would do. [1]

The main measure was the Insomnia Severity Index (ISI), a questionnaire about insomnia symptoms and their impact. A larger reduction means greater improvement. The researchers designed a non-inferiority trial: they asked whether tai chi's result stayed within a preset acceptable gap of four ISI points compared with CBT-I. [1]

Tai chi and CBT-I trial timeline Randomise 200 adults equally to tai chi or CBT-I. Each group attends 24 one-hour sessions over three months. At month 3, tai chi is inferior to CBT-I. At month 15, tai chi meets the four-point non-inferiority margin. Randomise 200 adults · 100 in each group 3 months of sessions 24 × 1 hour per group Month 3: tai chi inferior ISI reduction: tai chi 6.67 CBT-I 11.19 Month 15: tai chi non-inferior ISI reduction: tai chi 9.51 CBT-I 10.18 · margin: 4 points
Months are counted from the start of the trial. Month 15 was about a year after the sessions ended. [1]

Key findings

Average reduction in ISI score from the start of the trial. Larger reductions mean greater improvement. [1]
Time pointTai chiCBT-I
Month 36.67 points11.19 points
Month 159.51 points10.18 points

At month 3, tai chi was inferior. The early improvement was smaller, and the uncertainty around the difference extended beyond the four-point margin.

“Tai chi was deemed inferior to CBT-I at month 3 because the upper confidence limit exceeded the non-inferiority margin.”

— Siu et al., BMJ 2025, Results. [1: Full text]

At month 15, tai chi met the non-inferiority rule. The reported between-group difference was 0.68 ISI points, and the upper confidence limit stayed within the four-point margin. This supports a similar longer-term result within that margin; it does not establish that the two approaches are identical. [1]

“At this point, tai chi was considered non-inferior to CBT-I because the upper confidence limit fell within the non-inferiority margin.”

— Siu et al., BMJ 2025, Results at month 15. [1: Full text]

No adverse events were observed during the intervention. That finding covers the three-month program in these participants; it does not establish that either approach is risk-free for everyone.

“No adverse events were observed in either group during the intervention period.”

— Siu et al., BMJ 2025, Results. [1: Full text]

What this doesn't tell us

This was a single-centre study in Hong Kong with Chinese participants, most of them aged 60 or over. The findings may not carry over to younger adults or other settings. Gaps in follow-up add uncertainty, and continued practice after the program was not well tracked. We cannot tell how much later tai chi practice contributed to the month 15 result. [1]

What to take away

In this trial, CBT-I brought greater improvement by the end of the classes. Tai chi's results improved over a longer period and met the study's comparison threshold at month 15. For someone considering their options, the structured class commitment and the time needed to see improvement both matter.

Read more about CBT-I and why guidelines recommend it first, or explore sleep hygiene for background on everyday sleep habits.

Reference

  1. BMJ 2025[1] Siu PM, et al. Tai chi or cognitive behavioural therapy for treating insomnia in middle aged and older adults: randomised non-inferiority trial. BMJ. 2025;391:e084320.
    DOI: 10.1136/bmj-2025-084320 · Full text

This article is for education only and isn't medical advice. If sleep problems persist, talk with a doctor or a trained CBT-I provider about your options.